#machining#cnc#fanuc#electronics

Fucking up a CNC mill and saving it

This month, I had the honor of fucking up the entirety of the control of my Hermle.

Alarm 101: PLEASE CLEAR MEMORY

Everything started when this alarm appeared on the control. I had never seen it before, so of course my first reflex was to google it. That quickly led me to believe it was a non-critical error and I would just have to delete my programs. That didn’t matter much: the control has so little memory by modern standards (120 m of tape ≈\approx 48 kB) that I only ever kept the program(s) for the current job on it anyway. Everything else I read in over RS232.

And if anything went wrong, I had a full backup of the parameters (so I thought.)

Resetting Memory

So, looking through some forum posts and the official FANUC Maintenance Manual, I quickly found out the RAM could be cleared by pressing various combinations of keys during startup. The official manual says POWER ON + DELETE. That did nothing, so I thought I had misread it. In the back of my mind I had POWER ON + RESET + DELETE, which I had also read somewhere. I tried that and …

FUCK.

I had deleted the entirety of the RAM instead of just the programs. Even then I wasn’t panicking completely. I had a backup, after all. So I went to work: I opened the parameters page (there were no other pages left anyway), connected my laptop with the backup loaded and pressed INPUT, like I usually do to import stuff over serial.

Nothing worked. The manual didn’t help, so I asked the clanker, and it came up with a key combination: EOB + INPUT, which allows serial input in modes other than EDIT. I tried it for half an hour in different configurations and watched the bytes going over the serial line in all sorts of applications. Nothing happened. Not even the things I knew from my first months with the machine: the 086 not-ready alarm, or the blinking LSK/INPUT that should appear during communication.

I gave up and sent pleas for help to the Zerspanungsbude Forum, Fanuc and Hermle Support. It was the weekend so I had no option but to wait. In the meantime, the people on the forum pointed out that I would also need the DIAGNOSIS parameters, which I didn’t have a backup of. FUUUCK.

Right after the wipe, every axis showed a DGTL PARAM alarm on top of the usual ones, which means the servo parameters were gone:

the Fanuc 0-M control in the workshop, showing servo alarms for all three axes

With nothing else to do while RS232 didn’t work, I started keying in thousands of parameters by hand. It only helped a little: the “missing parameter” alarms for the servos went away, but the machine was still in NOT READY state and nothing you would want to do on a mill worked.

Helpful Support??

The first people who answered were FANUC support. They were very helpful and surprisingly understanding of me running a 40 year old machine in production. The service tech on the phone told me about parameter 901: one of its bits tells the control that the serial interface exists at all. After the wipe it was off, so that’s why the control ignored everything I sent.

From Hermle I had asked for pretty much everything I could think of: the PMC ladder and its parameters (keep relays, data table, timers, counters), a standard parameter list for my serial number, whether the ladder lives in ROM or RAM, and a service partner near Düsseldorf who still works on this generation of controls.

An hour later, even Hermle answered. First, just to tell me they couldn’t help me, then, half an hour later they surprisingly found the factory backup of all parameters for my exact machine. As someone who normally mostly deals with consumer customer support I was flabbergasted and very happy. They sent me three dumps (probably written on MS-DOS and saved on some server for the last 40 years): the parameters, a nearly identical copy of the parameters I did not see the use of AND the DIAGNOSIS parameters (300–499) for which I had already given up all hope.

Serial Troubles. Again.

With this new boost of motivation, I got straight to work. Parameter 901 is part of the 900 range, which holds the options the original customer bought. None of the backups (Hermle’s or mine) included them, but I found a PDF with a complete list. I set the bit in 901 that enables the serial interface, rebooted and finally arrived at an old friend of mine.

086 P/S ALARM

The DR signal alarm. Huh? I hadn’t changed anything about the hardware setup I had arrived at after lots of trial and error earlier in the year, and my transfer application was the same too. So it had to be one of the thousands of parameters I had just retyped, and I had no idea which one.

Annoying, but then I just had to do the hack I had found too annoying the first time: jumpering DR on the connector, so it’s set electrically instead of by the adapter. I jammed a few strands of stranded wire from a broken USB-C cable straight into the DE9 and DB25 connectors (both, to be safe :D) and went from the 086 alarm to … the 087 alarm. Now that DR was always high, the control never stopped reading. If I pressed Send on my laptop too slowly, the control timed out waiting, and sending afterwards led to the overflow alarm. So I just had to reboot every time something went wrong. Small price to pay.

Loading the full parameter backup

So I loaded the backup. Right after rebooting, more alarms went away and more of the UI looked like it used to. Apparently typing thousands of parameters by hand is not one of my natural talents. I had gotten further, but the machine was still unusable: the axes didn’t move, and AUTO and EDIT modes still didn’t work (as far as I could tell).

I also couldn’t open the PMC ladder screen anymore, so I was really worried the ladder was gone. That would probably have been the death sentence for the 0M control. Reflashing it without a backup, with a proprietary MS-DOS tool from the 80s, did not seem feasible.

At least the alarm list got shorter. Only the DETECT ERR alarms for the three axes were left, plus alarm 100, which just means parameter writing is still enabled:

after loading the backup: only the servo “detect error” alarms are left

Enabling options

Most of the time, the control didn’t even get past its boot screen. All it showed was the software version and NOT READY:

the screen it was stuck on without E-stop

The option parameters (900–923) tell the control which features the original customer paid for. Each one is a byte, and each bit is one option. Apart from the RS232 bit they were all still zero, and one of them turned out to be the reason nothing worked: parameter 905, which tells the control which PMC (the PLC running Hermle’s ladder logic) is installed.

905 bit PMC
0 PMC-L
1 PMC-M 3000 steps
2 PMC-M 5000 steps
3 PMC-M 8000 steps
4 PMC-M 12000 steps

With all bits cleared, the ladder (which luckily lives in ROM, not RAM) never runs. That explained everything: the emergency stop signal goes through the PMC, so no PMC means permanently NOT READY. The mode keys are read by the PMC too, so the control was stuck in MDI, and of course there was no PMC screen. I couldn’t find a PMC-M board in the cabinet, so it had to be the built-in PMC-L: 905 = 00000001. Reboot, and the PMC screen was back. And with it, I could finally home the machine again.

Then I went through the option list and set the bits for the features the machine had:

Param Value Options
900 00001011 canned cycles, G10 offset input, handwheel (MPG)
901 11100010 120 m tape memory, chamfering/corner radius, reader/puncher interface (RS232), multiple repetitive canned cycles
903 10110100 actual spindle speed output, MDI B, 125 programs, soft keys below the CRT
905 00000001 PMC-L
906 00010000 99 offsets
907 01010000 run hour/parts count display, cutter compensation C (G41/G42)
909 10000000 simple tool life management
910 11011111 program restart, work offsets (G54–G59), operator messages, helical interpolation, F1-digit feed, automatic corner override, thread cutting
911 00101101 single direction positioning, rigid tapping, clock and counters, 400 offsets
912 00110101 3rd/4th reference point return, G68 coordinate rotation, tool life management, 200 offsets
913 10000010 polar coordinates (G15/G16), user macro B
915 10000000 200 registerable programs
916 10000000 graphic display B
917 00010000 additional macro variables

Bit 0 is the rightmost digit. You have to type all eight digits and press INPUT, and after every change the control throws 000 and wants a power cycle.

Making parts again

After all of that, the machine is back to making parts even better than before, because I now have the cycle time option. Lessons learned: read the manual twice before holding down keys at power-on, and back up everything, including the DIAGNOSIS and option parameters. Here’s a picture of the first part I made after it ran again, a bracket for the robocup team of my little brother.

machined aluminium bracket with a center bore and four countersunk holes

Appendix: all option bits

Here is the full list of option bits for reference (✓ = enabled on my machine). I also made it into a PDF.

Param Bit Option
900 0 CANNED CYCLE ✓
900 1 G10 PROGRAM INPUT OF OFFSET ✓
900 2 MECHANICAL HANDLE FEED
900 3 MANUAL ONE PULSE GENERATOR CONTROL ✓
900 4 S4/S5 DIGIT CONTROL
900 5 INCH / METRIC CONVERSION
900 6 SPECIAL G CODE
901 0 TAPE MEMORY ADDITION 320M
901 1 TAPE MEMORY ADDITION 120M ✓
901 2 TAPE MEMORY ADDITION 80M
901 3 TAPE MEMORY ADDITION 40M
901 4 TAPE MEMORY ADDITION 20M
901 5 CHAMFERING, CORNER RADIUS ✓
901 6 READER/PUNCHER INTERFACE CONTROL ✓
901 7 MULTIPLE REPETITIVE CANNED CYCLE ✓
902 0 TWO MANUAL PULSE GENERATOR CONTROL
902 2 CONSTANT SURFACE SPEED CONTROL
902 3 SPINDLE SPEED FLUCTUATION DETECTION
902 4 PATTERN DATA INPUT
902 5 STORED PITCH ERROR COMPENSATION
902 6 CUSTOM MACRO A
902 7 PLAYBACK
903 0 MIRROR IMAGE FOR DOUBLE TURRETS
903 1 X AXIS MIRROR IMAGE
903 2 ACTUAL SPINDLE SPEED OUTPUT ✓
903 3 DIRECT INPUT OF OFFSET B
903 4 MDI EXEC. B ✓
903 5 NUMBER OF PROGRAMS 125 ✓
903 6 EXTERNAL KEY INPUT
903 7 SOFT KEYS BELOW CRT ✓
904 0 JAPANESE
904 1 GERMAN/FRENCH MESSAGE
904 2 CHINESE
904 3 ITALIAN
904 4 SPANISH
904 5 HANGEUL
905 0 PMC MODEL L ✓
905 1 PMC MODEL M 3000 STEP
905 2 PMC MODEL M 5000 STEP
905 3 PMC MODEL M 8000 STEP
905 4 PMC MODEL M 12000 STEP
906 0 MENU PROGRAMMING
906 3 ADDITIONAL OFFSET MEMORY 64
906 4 ADDITIONAL OFFSET MEMORY 99 ✓
906 5 TOOL LENGTH MEASUREMENT
906 7 EXTERNAL TOOL COMPENSATION
907 1 2ND AUXILIARY FUNCTION B 8-DIGIT BINARY
907 2 SIMULTANEOUS 3 AXIS CONTROL
907 3 ADDITIONAL AXIS CONTROL
907 4 HOUR RUN / PARTS COUNT DISPLAY ✓
907 6 CUTTER COMPENSATION C G41/G42 ✓
907 7 CUTTER COMPENSATION B
908 0 HANDLE INTERRUPTION
908 3 JOG OVERRIDE
908 5 GENERAL PURPOSE SOFTWARE OPERATOR’S PANEL
908 7 SOFTWARE OPERATOR’S PANEL
909 0 GRAPHICS DISPLAY
909 1 CONVERSATIONAL TYPE PROGRAMMING WITH FIGURE
909 3 STROKE LIMIT EXTERNAL SETTING
909 6 EXTERNAL MESSAGE
909 7 SIMPLE TOOL LIFE MANAGE ✓
910 0 PGM RESTART ✓
910 1 WORK OFFSETS G54-G59 ✓
910 2 OPER. MESSAGE ✓
910 3 HELICAL INT. ✓
910 4 F1 DIGIT FEED ✓
910 5 AXIS CONTROL BY PMC
910 6 AUTO. CORNER OVERRIDE ✓
910 7 THREAD CUTTING AND SYNCHRONOUS FEED ✓
911 0 SINGLE DIRECTION POSITIONING ✓
911 2 RIGID TAP ✓
911 3 CLOCK AND COUNTERS ✓
911 4 CHANGES XYZ TO @
911 5 400 OFFSETS ✓
911 6 DIRECTION DISPLAY OF FLOPPY CASSETTE
911 7 DECIMAL POINT DISPLAY
912 0 3RD / 4TH REFERENCE POINT RETURN ✓
912 1 G50, G51 SCALING
912 2 G68 COOR-SYS-ROTATE ✓
912 3 F10/11 TAPE FORMAT
912 4 TOOL LIFE MANAGEMENT ✓
912 5 200 OFFSETS ✓
912 6 ADDITIONAL OPTIONAL BLOCK SKIP 9
912 7 MACRO EXECUTER OR AUX / GRAPH DISPLAY
913 1 G15, G16 POLAR COORDINATE SYSTEM ✓
913 4 I/O DEVICE EXTERNAL CONTROL
913 5 SIMULTANEOUS 4 AXIS CONTROL
913 7 USER MACRO B ✓
914 1 REMOTE BUFFER STORAGE
914 2 HIGH SPEED REMOTE BUFFER STORAGE A
914 3 HIGH SPEED REMOTE BUFFER STORAGE B
914 4 READER PUNCHER INTERFACE CONTROL 2
915 5 5 AXIS CONTROL
915 7 200 REGISTERABLE PROGRAMS ✓
916 0 TOOL OFFSET G45-G48
916 7 GRAPHIC B ✓
917 4 ADDITIONAL MACRO VARIABLES 149-199, 531-999 ✓
923 5 48 WORK OFFSETS